Welcome to Sutter Deli
Sutter Deli is a delightful find tucked away on N Broadwell Ave in Grand Island, Nebraska. This charming deli serves up mouthwatering sandwiches, fresh salads, and decadent cookies that keep bringing locals and visitors back for more. With a cozy, antique decor, Sutter Deli offers a warm atmosphere that perfectly complements its hearty menu. Whether you choose to dine in, grab a takeaway, or opt for delivery, every meal promises satisfaction. Expect generous portions at surprisingly reasonable prices, typically ranging from $10 to $20. This hidden gem doesn’t just focus on delicious food; it creates a comforting community vibe that makes every visit feel special.
Popular dishes
Restaurant Gallery
About
Located at 371 N Broadwell Ave, Sutter Deli stands out as a beloved local eatery. This deli reflects the essence of Grand Island—friendly, welcoming, and community-focused. The moment you step inside, the antique decor and cozy atmosphere invite you to unwind and enjoy your meal. Sutter Deli takes pride in providing accessible dining options, ensuring that everyone can enjoy a fantastic meal without hindrance. Wheelchair-accessible facilities, including a parking lot and restroom, highlight the deli's commitment to inclusivity. The staff here are known for their warm smiles and attentive service, ensuring that everyone feels valued. Whether it’s a quick lunch on the go or a leisurely meal with friends, Sutter Deli adapts to every mood. During peak times like Friday lunch, the energy is bustling, but there are always quiet morning hours ideal for those who prefer a more peaceful dining experience. Supporting local businesses is a key part of the community's fabric, and Sutter Deli, with its inviting charm and delicious offerings, plays a crucial role in that.
Location & Contact
Address
371 N Broadwell Ave, Grand Island, NE 68803, United States
Hotline
+1 308-370-8942
Working Hours
- SundayOpen
- MondayOpen
- TuesdayOpen
- WednesdayOpen
- ThursdayOpen
- FridayOpen
- SaturdayOpen
What People Say
Most Liked
Locals rave about the sandwiches, especially the Sutter Reuben and the Trainwreck, known for their unique flavor combinations and generous portions. Customer reviews often highlight the delicious cookies, particularly the white chocolate macadamia nut and monster cookies, as must-tries. The deli’s comfy atmosphere creates a welcoming space where friends and families can gather, enhancing the dining experience. Additionally, friendly staff contribute to a positive vibe, ensuring no one leaves with unmet expectations. The affordability of meals, with most costing around $7.53 on average, adds to its appeal, making it an excellent spot for casual dining without breaking the bank.
Most Disliked
While many enjoy the offerings at Sutter Deli, some have noted peak hours can lead to longer wait times for lunch. As Fridays around noon hit 100% capacity, this busy time often leads to full tables and a bustling scene that may feel overwhelming to some. Those hoping for a quick meal during lunch rush may want to plan ahead or consider visiting early in the day. A few patrons have mentioned missing out on earlier hours when the deli opens, as it can close relatively early compared to other dining options. Finally, the limited dinner service may disappoint those seeking a late option; with average dinner popularity standing at 0%, late-night diners might need to look elsewhere.
Reviews
Quo L.
What a fantastic restaurant! I love the antique decor, but the food is the real highlight. The sandwiches and salads are delicious, with soft bread and generous portions. And don't miss their cookies—so sweet and decadent! Give this place a try; you won't be disappointed!
Wyatt W.
Amazing little sandwich shop that is worth a visit or two while in town! I was here visiting family and went back on two separate occasions. The turkey club was 10/10 and the cookies are also amazing. Wife loved the Sutters club and got it both times. Staff was extremely polite and friendly to everyone. Will definitely be back next time I’m in town.
Fate's D.
OMG! If you have never eaten here you HAVE to try it! I'm addicted to little hole in he wall, mom and pop shops of all kinds! This place is super adorable. They make AMAZING cookies🤤🤤🤤 and other delicious foods as well and their sandwiches have some super fun names! I don't get to eat here as often as I would like but I definitely want them to stay open for as many generations as possible!! 🥰🥰🥰 I've only lived in Grand Island for 4 years but this is so far the best family restaurant I've been to here so far. I can't wait to explore and find more!!
Martin P.
Ive come in twice a few minutes before closing and each time they always take my order so nicely and they’re so sweet, im so sorry i come in so late but these sandwiches are the best in town and i cant make it since i work nights haha
Ashley R.
This is a hidden gem! The good here is phenomenal everytime… a variety of sandwiches, soups, and salads… they also have a cozy home vibe that will keep your chops slobbering to come back. An Arnold Palmer, a train wreck, a Rueben, and the Chinese chicken salad are my go to’s of the menu! And white chocolate macadamia nut cookie or a monster cookie!
Geoff C.
Friendly place with an home style feel. Casual for sure. Just don't be in a hurry.
Howard C.
Our 2nd lunch here. It is delicious. Thinking about this lunch since waking up in Wyoming. Road trip.